Resale Record

Home / Blog

How to calculate your real profit on an eBay sale

A calculator, a packed box and a handwritten price tag on a desk

The number on the sale screen is not your profit. The honest figure is what is left after everything that item cost you, and it is almost always smaller than it feels.

The formula

Profit = sale price (plus any shipping the buyer paid) − what you paid for the item − selling fees − shipping you paid − supplies.

A worked example

You buy a jacket at a thrift store for $12. It sells for $60 and the buyer pays $8 shipping.

Amount
Sale price $60.00
Shipping paid by buyer $8.00
What you paid −$12.00
Marketplace and payment fees (illustrative) −$9.00
Postage you bought −$9.50
Mailer and tape −$1.00
Profit $36.50

The fee line is an example. Fees vary by category and change over time, so use the figures from your own sales report rather than a rule of thumb.

Margin and return

Profit alone hides how efficient you were. Two useful ratios: profit divided by sale price (margin) and profit divided by what you paid (return on cost). A $5 profit on a $4 item and on a $40 item are very different results.

Include your time, honestly

The calculation above leaves out the hour you spent finding, photographing, listing and packing the jacket. You do not need to put a number on your time in your books, but it explains why a $3 profit is usually not worth a $2 item.

Why the cost is the usual gap

Fees and shipping come in automatically when sales are synced. Your purchase price does not, because eBay never saw it. That is why sales with no recorded cost overstate profit. Record the cost when you buy and the calculation takes care of itself.

You can also check what an item really sold for before you buy, so the margin is known in advance.

Keep your resale books in one place

Resale Record logs pickups, tracks sales, mileage and expenses, and has your Schedule C export ready at tax time. It is on Google Play for Android, and in a private beta on TestFlight for iPhone and iPad.

Get it on Google Play   or request iPhone beta access

General information, not tax advice. Check anything that affects your return with a tax preparer.